Which of the following is considered a disadvantage of relying on case law?

Which of the following is considered a disadvantage of relying on case law?

• A. Certainty in decisions
• B. Volumes of reporters
• C. Predictable outcomes
• D. Clear precedents

Answer: (B)

Relying on case law can indeed be associated with a significant disadvantage when considering the sheer volume of reporters and legal cases that exist. This abundance of reported cases can overwhelm legal practitioners and those trying to rely on case law as guidance. It may lead to challenges in finding relevant precedents, as the increase in available cases can make it more difficult to discern which cases truly apply to a particular legal issue. The complexity and extent of the body of case law can create a situation where important rulings may be overlooked, affecting the ability to achieve a well-informed legal outcome. In contrast to this, certainty in decisions, predictable outcomes, and clear precedents are advantages associated with case law, as they help formulate a legal framework that promotes stability and predictability in adjudication. These features tend to provide a stronger foundation for legal reasoning and guidance, in stark contrast to the challenges posed by the volume of reported cases.

Relying on case law can indeed be associated with a significant disadvantage when considering the sheer volume of reporters and legal cases that exist. This abundance of reported cases can overwhelm legal practitioners and those trying to rely on case law as guidance. It may lead to challenges in finding relevant precedents, as the increase in available cases can make it more difficult to discern which cases truly apply to a particular legal issue. The complexity and extent of the body of case law can create a situation where important rulings may be overlooked, affecting the ability to achieve a well-informed legal outcome.

In contrast to this, certainty in decisions, predictable outcomes, and clear precedents are advantages associated with case law, as they help formulate a legal framework that promotes stability and predictability in adjudication. These features tend to provide a stronger foundation for legal reasoning and guidance, in stark contrast to the challenges posed by the volume of reported cases.